| Platinum | Jokers IceHouse Bar & Grill |
| Gold | The Heights Pizza |
| Silver | Pierino's Pasta & Pizza to Go |
| Bronze | Area 254 |
| Top Pick | Bebos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bobby Lupo's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Brick and Forge |
| Top Pick | Marco's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tony's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Village Pizza |