| Platinum | Pruebalo'To |
| Gold | Culture Cuisine |
| Silver | Mon'Amie's Caribbean Flava Ice |
| Bronze | Jamaican Nyammings |
| Top Pick | 1 Luv Island Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Coqui Cafe |
| Top Pick | CostaMar Seafood & Grill Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Island Spice Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Killeen Nutritional Center (la Tiendita) |
| Top Pick | La Garita |